Legislation & Regulation
Mining Organizations Unite To Petition For Rule Change
July 2019 by Scott Harn
Eleven mining organizations signed on to a “Petition for Rulemaking to Stop State-Law-Based Prohibitions of Mining on Federal Lands.”
5 U.S.C. § 553(e) states, “Each agency shall give an interested person the right to petition for the issuance, amendment, or repeal of a rule.”
Working with attorney James Buchal, a petition was drafted to Interior Secretary David Bernhardt and Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue that highlights the abuses miners have faced from overzealous state regulators.
As many of you know from reading our publication, the US Supreme Court declined to hear the People v. Rinehart case that dealt with the State of California’s requiring a permit for suction gold dredging and then refusing to issue such permit.
This was followed by the Bohmker v. Oregon case, where the State of Oregon banned motorized methods of in-stream mining. The US Supreme Court also declined to hear this case.
The six-page petition points out that the intent of Congress and federal preemption are being circumvented by states like California and Oregon.
From the petition:
“It is fundamentally both Departments’ duty to avoid ‘unnecessary or undue degradation of federal lands’ (43 U.S.C. § 1732(b); emphasis added), while managing federal land ‘in a manner that recognizes the Nation’s need for domestic sources of minerals’ (id. § 1701(a)(12)). Congress recognized that minerals (or energy resources) must be recovered where they lie, and that some level of environmental impact is necessary. In particular, Congress has forbidden both Agriculture and Interior from issuing federal regulations which would ‘materially interfere with prospecting, mining or processing operations or uses’ of land claimed under the federal mining laws. United States v. Backlund, 689 F.3d 986, 996 n.9 (9th Cir. 2012) (interpreting 30 U.S.C. § 612(b)).”
The petition seeks specific changes to existing Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management regulations to restore the intent of Congress and federal preemption.
This dovetails well with the legislative changes we’ve been seeking in Washington, DC. Although we would rather see the regulations changed via Congress to make it more difficult for another administration to reverse them, this action would definitely help provide regulatory relief in the near term.
Organizations that wish to support this effort are encouraged to do so by writing their own letter addressed to Secretary Bernhardt and Secretary Perdue. I’ve offered to collect them and forward them on to Tom Kitchar of the Waldo Mining District for so they can be presented to the agencies. Please try to get those letters to me sooner rather than later, but no later than July 25.
Support letters can be emailed to me at firstname.lastname@example.org or sent by mail:
ICMJ—Petition for Rulemaking
PO Box 2260
Aptos, CA 95001
(The full “Petition for Rulemaking” can be viewed by clicking on the letter above.)
Legislative and Regulatory Update
• Obama’s parting shots
• California suction dredging
• Oregon follows California’s lead
• Lawsuit coming; bill introduced to stop mining in Washington State
• President Trump halts new federal regulations
Small Miner Beats Forest Service in Court
Thomas Tierney has been a long-time subscriber to ICMJ’s Prospecting and Mining Journal and has read about the many battles between miners and overzealous regulators. Then he faced his own battle.
In May 2017, the district participated in a meeting with representatives from several state and federal agencies where they educated agency officials about the authority of Mining Districts, Mining Law and miner’s rights.
Taking on the EPA, Sasquatch, Ratchilla and Gold Dredging
...we packed up our two dredges and headed for our claim about an hour away on the South Fork of the Clearwater to dredge openly in opposition to the EPA.
Legislative and Regulatory Update
• Oregon's attack on suction gold dredging
• New DOI Director nominated
• More Forest Service restrictions in the works
• California suction gold dredging
Revised Dredge Regulations Published for California—Pure Garbage
We can’t say it wasn’t expected. The California Department of Fish & Game released revised suction gold dredging regulations on February 17, 2012, and it’s obvious the agency wants to make life as difficult as possible for dredgers.
Prospectors Protest San Gabriel Mountains National Monument
More than 100 gold prospectors gathered at Azusa Canyon in the recently declared San Gabriel Mountains National Monument in southern California to voice their concerns…
The Bawl Mill • Ask The Experts - Diamonds in the Mother Lode? • Ask The Experts - How do I set up my shaker table? • Ask The Experts - Does silicone rubber make a good sluice mat? • Ask The Experts - Conflicting assays for platinum group elements • Get Boots On The Ground For Patch Hunting • Lessons Learned From Geologists • Gold Prospecting for Better or Worse: Man vs Paydirt • Mohave County, Arizona: The Oatman/San Francisco Mining District • ICMJ Honored As Prospecting Magazine of the Year • The Sunbaker • A Golden Vacation • Mining Company Pays Millions for Gold Dug From Mine Dumps • Melman on Gold & Silver • Mining Stock Quotes and Mineral & Metal Prices